A couple thorny locusts

Honey locust

This is a young and healthy specimen of Honey locust (Gleditsia triacanthos).  It has long red thorns along its branches.  Here’s another close view of the thorns . . .

Honey locustOn a mature Honey locust tree, clusters of these large, multi-branched thorns grow along the tree’s trunk.  (The brown leaves in the background belong to an American beech–Fagus grandifolia.)

Honey locustThe thorns are large enough to see at a some distance from the tree . . .

Honey locustNext, is another thorny locust (with similar-looking compound leaves).  This is a very young Black locust (Robinia pseudoacacia).  This specimen is so young that its new branches and thorns are both reddish in color.

Black locustThis next specimen of a Black locust branch shows its small thorns.  The bits of green are newly sprouting leaves in the spring.

Black locustAnd this image shows the thorns as they grow along the Black locust’s branches.

Black locustNow look at the trunk of a maturing Black locust.  In contrast to the Honey locust, this tree’s thorns are barely visible along the trunk.

Black locustJust in case you couldn’t see the one visible thorn in the above image, here it is again in a closer view.

Black locustNow for some botanical terminology with definitions from Plant Identification Terminology by James G. Harris and Melinda Woolf Harris.  “Thorn” is defined as “a stiff, woody, modified stem with a sharp point; sometimes applied to any structure resembling a true thorn.”

“Spine” is “a stiff, slender, sharp-pointed structure arising from below the epidermis, representing a modified leaf or stipule.”

“Prickle” is “a small, sharp outgrowth of the epidermis or bark.”

And here’s another set of definitions — this time from How to Identify Plants by H. D. Harrington.

Thorn.  A stiff, hard, sharp-pointed emergence more deeply seated than a prickle.  By some, differentiated from a spine in having vascular tissue.”

Spine.  A sharp-pointed rigid deep-seated outgrowth from the stem, not pulling off with the bark. . .  Sometimes differentiated from thorn by absence of vascular tissue.”

Prickle.  A small, usually slender outgrowth of the young bark, coming off with it.”

One final set of definitions from The Kew Plant Glossary by Henk Beentje:

thorn, 1. short pointed woody structure derived from a reduced branch; 2. often applied (wrongly) in a looser sense for any sharp structure on a branch”

spine, a sharp-pointed, hardened structure derived from a leaf, stipule, root or branch, but always originating from the vascular or woody part.  (Thorn is derived from a reduced branch, pointed structures from the epidermis are called prickles)”

prickle, . . .  a sharp outgrowth from the epidermis, detachable without tearing the organ”

Given these definitions, what term would you apply to the “thorns” of each of these locust trees?

This entry was posted in Plant comparisons. Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to A couple thorny locusts

  1. Josh Fecteau says:

    Hm… tough one. I’d say both trees have spines, but Honey-locust (Gleditsia triacanthos) also has thorns.

  2. Honey NO-cust says:

    I pruned all mine at the bottom. They are prolific re-sprouters. They would only be useful if that was the only tree you had.

    • mensasnem says:

      I gently and delicately pruned all of my to the ground — and painted the stumps with brush killer to prevent them from stump sprouting. Kept my house warm for the winter.

      Next on the list are Osage Orange and a truly worthless weed commonly known at Elm.

  3. Victor Huston says:

    Could you tell me which tree and its thorns would have been used to make the crown of thorns Jesus was forced to endure? Thanks

  4. Jim Loyd says:

    Do you know of something similar that takes the form of a bush (3′-5′ high) rather than a tree? I once saw a bush with nasty thorns planted in a wide swath outside the walls of an 18th century fort. The purpose was to have a natural barrier (perhaps 20′ wide) that would prevent attackers from getting close to the fort’s walls.

    • Angelyn says:

      I do not know what plant you might have seen. There are varying possibilities, given the region and which plants typically grow there. And if a tree is coppiced (cut down repeatedly), it will put out many more stems/branches which can grow thickly together.

  5. Me says:

    Are these locust trees poisonous?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.